Skip to content
Katalog Solusi

Cacao Pod Breaker (3)

Slow performance and unsafe extraction of cacao beans from the pods

2/4 - Moderate Agriculture & Fisheries 2024

Summary

We tested the speed and safety of cacao pod breaker V3 to cacao farmers in Pajahan, Bali.

Why we rated it this way

In terms of speed, there was a slight increase in V3 compared to V2, yet the machete is still a faster method compared to the pod breaker. However, farmers prefer the V3 over machete for safety.

The problem

What we found

In 2022, Indonesia emerged as the third-largest global producer of cacao beans, yielding approximately 667.3 thousand metric tons (Source: Statista). In Indonesia, smallholder farmers play a significant role in driving the cacao industry, contributing significantly to cacao production compared to large plantations. However, they still fully rely on a traditional approach of processing cacao.The speed of cacao seed extraction is crucial during post-harvest processing, especially when farmers intend to ferment the beans. Fermentation boxes typically require 500-650 kilograms of cacao beans, and failing to meet this quantity can result in lower quality fermentation. To ensure high-quality fermentation, the seeds must be quickly extracted from the pods.

 

After harvesting cacao pods, typical farmers in Indonesia use machetes to crack them. This practice poses a major risk as repetitive and forceful movements with a machete can cause musculoskeletal injuries. Additionally, the long working hours and associated stress further contribute to health risks. From our observation, almost all farmers in Yapsi, Jayapura also experienced these risks, especially minor cuts.

 

In the previous experiment, farmers in Yapsi highlighted several limitations of V2.1 and V2.2 tools that hindered its usability and effectiveness. The tools required significant force to operate, particularly when cracking two pods simultaneously, leading to increased physical strain. The reliance on a two-clamp system to stabilize the tool was another drawback, as it necessitates flat, stable surfaces, which are not always available in rural settings. These issues reduced the tool's practicality and usability for smallholder

Cacao Pod Breaker (3)

The solution

What we tested

To address these challenges, the new cacao pod breaker V3 was designed for enhanced safety and practicality. Made from lighter and more affordable wood, the V3 tool with a longer handle reduces strain while cracking one pod at a time to simplify operation. A stabilized base plate eliminates the need for clamps on uneven surfaces.

Cacao Pod Breaker (3)

Project design

How we ran it

The experiment consisted of two groups. The first group, the control group, used a machete, a common tool among smallholder cacao farmers in Indonesia. The second group used the cacao pod breaker (V3). In total, 67 cacao pods were divided between the two groups. The participants were two cacao farmers from Pajahan, Bali.


We focused on three key indicators during the experiment:

1. Processing speed: We measured the rate of cacao pod processing in terms of pods per minute.
2. Safety: We asked the farmers to compare the safety of the machete and the V3 pod breaker.
3. User preference and feedback: We collected feedback from the farmers regarding their preference and overall experience in opening cacao pods using both methods.

Project design diagram for Cacao Pod Breaker (3)

The technology

New design for cacao pod breaker
New design for cacao pod breaker
First test of V3 prior to Pajahan visit
First test of V3 prior to Pajahan visit
Cracked cacao pods
Cracked cacao pods
Cacao farmers using the pod breaker V3
Cacao farmers using the pod breaker V3
CPB-infested cacao pod identified after cracking
CPB-infested cacao pod identified after cracking

Results

What we learned

In terms of processing speed, the treatment group using the cacao pod breaker V3 processed 10.8% fewer cacao beans, operating at 2.8 pods per minute compared with the control group’s 3.1 pods per minute. This indicates that the pod breaker may require further improvements to enhance its efficiency. However, compared to the previous version, the cacao pod breaker V3 showed some speed improvements.


Regarding the safety, the experiment showed that farmers preferred the cacao pod breaker V3 over the traditional machete, citing significant safety benefits.


The design improvements—such as a thinner body and increased leverage achieved through a longer handle, and metal-based chain hinges— may have contributed to the speed gains compared to earlier designs. Although the pod breaker remains slower than the machete, it achieved a 100% user preference rate over the machete.


Additionally, based on farmer feedback, a notch was added to improve the tool's grip on cacao pods, tailored to the average pod size. This adjustment is expected to further enhance usability and effectiveness. Farmers also suggested using even lighter wood materials or a more compact design to improve handling, particularly for the challenging terrain of Pajahan’s cacao farms.

Results chart for Cacao Pod Breaker (3)
Results chart for Cacao Pod Breaker (3)

Conclusion

The V3 tool showed some improvement in pod-breaking speed compared to the V2 variants, yet the machete remains the fastest method tested so far. However, farmers prefer the cacao pod breaker V3 for its safety.

Read more

Project profile

https://www.kopernik.info/en/current-projects/improving-the-cacao-postharvest-process-with-a-cacao-pod-breaker