Hermetic Bag and Drum and Food Grade Pesticide for Grain Storage
Loss of grains due to weevil infestation during storage
Summary
We added a natural pesticide to our grain storage solutions to test whether it would further reduce weevil infestation.
Why we rated it this way
While adding a natural pesticide to stored grains significantly reduced weevils, due to lack of control group, the results of the experiment is inconclusive. The reduction of weevils could have been caused by other factors.
The problem
What we found
In many developing countries, including Indonesia, more than one-third of food is lost during the post-harvest period, with 50-60 percent of grain losses occurring during storage. Two of the major food crops in East Nusa Tenggara province (NTT) are sorghum and maize. Farmers lose between 30-70% of stored grain because traditional storage methods do not provide adequate protection against weevils or rodents.
In the two previous project phases, Kopernik found that a hermetically sealed plastic drum and a hermetic storage plastic bag can reduce weevils by up to 64% as compared to the traditionally used method. Moreover, keeping the storage containers closed for six months (as opposed to opening them each month) further reduced the number of weevils up to 98%. However these techniques did not allow farmers to access their stock of grain in storage as they need. A solution is therefore needed to stop the weevils surviving in the storage containers whilst still allowing them to be opened regularly.
The solution
What we tested
In this phase, we added a natural pesticide, Diatomaceous Earth (DE), to the storage methods to allow farmers to open their storage containers regularly without compromising grain protection. This was done by comparing the number of weevils present using this solution against the results observed in the previous phases.
Project design
How we ran it
In this project, we replicated the treatment from the two previous phases of the experiment. From May to October 2020, we tested three storage methods:
- A hermetically sealed plastic drum (180kg capacity)
- A hermetic plastic bag (60kg capacity) placed inside the traditionally used woven plastic sack
- A traditionally used woven plastic sack (60kg capacity)
We filled each storage container to full capacity and added food grade Diatomaceous Earth (DE) with a ratio between grains and DE of 1kg:1gram. We took 600 grams of sorghum as a sample from each storage container each month for six months. We then compared the total number of weevils, dead and alive, against the results of Phase I.
The technology
Results
What we learned
We found that three grain storage methods (traditional, hermetic bag, and hermetic drum) with DE significantly reduced the number of weevils by 98%. Further, farmers can open the storage containers without risking their grain being infested by weevils.
Of the three storage methods, the hermetic drum was found to be the most effective in keeping the grain weevil-free for the first five months of the experiment period.
However, due to the absence of a control group (storage without DE), we cannot exclude the possibility that the reduction of weevils was caused by other factors. The results of the experiment is therefore inconclusive.
Conclusion
While all three grain storage methods with DE saw significant reduction of weevils, The result of the experiment is inconclusive. Kopernik will further investigate the effectiveness of DE with more robust methodology.
Read more
Reports and references
Putri, Tungga D. W. (2019). Increasing Farmer Food Security and Incomes: Grain Storage Solutions Phase Three Project Report.
